hi all, normally i am more the reader than the writer but i would like to make a comment.
my home shard is one of "European" shards.
after years of break a friend took me to a IDOC beginning of the year. it was existing for me, having chats, fights in Fel (or in tram with a harbinger...) and try to get a few items when the house fell. i loved it. of course one or the other item landed afterwards in my house or bank, i am far from making billions but for my thoughts i am lucky. (could n´t even think how to farm this money...).
spoken in most of your words: a beginner, but i can live with that.
IDOC for me was also with the old system not easy, i have a full time job and the fall times on my shard were mostly between 2 and 5 in the night... which make it not easy if you have to get up a around 6...
now after the change its is nearly impossible because i cannot sit beside a house 24hours and wait till its fall. therefore the known times of the old at least gave people like me a chance to be there.
since the change i was at 1 IDOC (trammel castle, with a secret chest) mainly i was there because i had to do some work on the PC and was able to put my char beside the chest. There where around 10-15 chars arrived in a very short period (around 1 hours before falling) which brings me to the conclusion that its maybe not so random as someone thinks.
of course there were the usual's i saw already in the past.
the fall it self gave me no chance to even click the mouse key till the chest was gone, so much about "help against scripting" ... luckily the "grabber" dropped the chest somehow and i was beside it but that´s another topic.
for me personally IDOC is done (it was a real adventure but everything has to end...) because i can´t and of course will not plan my life after UO so that i can stay 24 hours beside a castle to get a peace of pixel when i´am lucky and no scripter is around.
in my eyes the change make the rich ones just more rich and people like me cannot even plan a bit to get lucky at least sometimes.
-> ah there is a public castle with nice items falling tonight at around 5, okay i can go a bit more early to bad and try my luck. -> no longer happening.
my suggestion are the following:
1. go back (...)
2. totally random drop with no indication at all, let the items stand on the ground for a few days so that everybody who is willing to walk over the land may find them
3. ad a timer to the house sigh with exact point when it fall, but release the items a random amount later (every time different) then everybody can be there and no one needs to complain. but make house private as soon as the timer start so no one can use script looting inside the house. (yes there may be a bug to look inside -> fix the bug... UO code is more than 15 years old how complicate can this be...)
4. put the stuff random based in the player banks of active accounts "a gift from a former UO player" -> random items / stacks with a counter per account and when all active accounts have one items start again etc...
Greetings,
Waxx