Oh goodness, theres a lot of great ideas here. Time to collate for sure.
Arties and Stealables
You gotta admit, theres a lot of these out there. They hardly sell (everyone has what they want, the rest is vendor junk) and its maybe time to wind down the drop rates.
Appropriate Types:
Doom
Paragon
Minor Arties
Tokuno
Points based on level/location of item. Maybe rarity level. Since non-stackable, hand-ins of 1.
Holiday Rewards
Everyones got a lot of this stuff. Whether its in a lockdown in a house, filling up alt character bank accounts, or sitting uselessly on vendors, theres far too much of it. Candy, bells, globes, snowflakes etc etc.
Appropriate Types:
All year levels.
Points based on age (possibly). With this kind of item where theres a lot of bulk product that doesnt stack, perhaps the collection NPCs can hand out trade-in bags. Must be handed back in with preset quantities (10's, 15's etc) and points can be tiered to whats being handed in.
Fishing Loot
I can remember loving the heck out of portraits and paintings when I first started fishing them up. Now they go in the trashcan. Ive got too many of them, everyone has too many of them. Same goes for everything "...recovered from a shipwreck". Much like the holiday items, lets bag em up in minimums, and hand them in.
Powerscrolls
Everyone holds out for a +20 anyway, whats the point of having 10 times as many +10s and 15s that no-one will ever use.
Points value for single 15's, possibly minimum of 5 for the 10's.
BODs
Much like powerscrolls, most folks simply farm the NPCs to get higher levelled BODs. Hands up who has 100's and 100's of BODs stored away, that youll never complete. I thought so.
Large minimum quantity turn in, for a medium to low point cost. BODs are readily available with no risk what-so-ever, so whilst I can appreciate turning them in and clearing server clutter, we shouldnt be over-compensated for it.
--------------------------
Great thread folks, hopefully Jeremy is popping his head in for a look.