I actually like the smaller rooms for crafting....I can reach everything I need from one spot and don't have to move...yeah ultimate lazy person syndrome.....I have it! I did have my crafting stuff on the roof of my castle at one point....HUGE soulforge smack dab in the middle and all the other stuff around it...it looked nice but was a PAIN to craft anything...the less I have to move, the better...especially when it comes to crafting because so much is needed for some things and I sometimes have many bags/backpacks open just so I can get more material quickly....then if I move they all close :/ So for me? Smaller is better.
that is my current crafting area, I have every craft and without moving I can inscribe, make pots, load up for my fishing, craft my cannon supplies, imbue, tailor anything, cook , smith , tinker, make furniture, do my fletching and craft with stone. I can reach the bin for throwing away, unravel all waste, fill all my spellbooks, and dye anything needed to be dyed. I do not move at all unless I am going to spin/loom cloth where I will take one step sth. I still don't like tiny rooms. You don't need tiny rooms to be able to be efficient in your crafting, in fact it is more efficient to have a bit of space around you. I will have the same set up in ANY building I am in. I can have ten friends standing in the space with me chatting without them getting in my way tho, as the room isn't confined to a 4 x 5 tile space with walls and doors.
In that space is the total of all my resources stored and put away from leather to ingots to wood, to regs, scrolls, gems and imbuing ingredients. When i return from hunting one set of chests takes the entirety of my loot bags for putting away, imbuing or trashing. The centre of the arcane circle is the 'spot' to access everything. It is the most efficient use of space and it wouldn't matter if I had ten castles lined up side by side this 'area' would be the same set up. It is a minimum of 6 x 6 open space fully visible with no walls 'hiding' stuff, I may take one step sth or east when putting scrolls away but that is all .
It's funny I sometimes craft suits for people and they might stand just on the other side of the chests to the east while I do it. Because I don't have to move they sometimes think I have timed out and I often get asked 'are you there?' as I stand still and make the suit, reforge it needed, imbue it, dye it without moving an inch. I am there of course just busy with a bunch of chests open! I run shops on all shards I play and craft everything possible to stock em. Have to be efficient in how you do it.
If the space was smaller than that then it wouldn't be practical nor aesthetically pleasing. I have found that minimum 6x6 area the most efficient type of crafting area.
If you like tiny rooms all good, as I said, each to their own, I just find them seriously limiting.
Oh and I NEVER have a room for tailoring one for smithing one for imbuing and all that mucking about. That is a mugs game. I have one crafting area and devote the rest of any space I have for socialising and deco. I learnt after my first UO house 14 years or so ago not to go down that route
It is interesting to see how people like to do things but gimme space any day lol.
Oh and another tip with a set up like this, if you run the EC when I get back from hunting I stand on the dot and run my 'gem' organizer, it puts all gems and imbuing ingredients away, i then run my regs organizer, then my resources organizer, and just stand there while it puts everything in the appropriate chest. I also have one for mage scrolls, nec scrolls, etc. I loot everything useful when I hunt given I run shops. Makes life very easy. I know where EVERYTHING is in my places. I think I am the ultimate lazy crafter, only I am not actually lazy I work hard.