Yeah and my first two accounts, which have fully maxed chars on gated in, got their gifts and recalled and there was NOTHING there cept one/two players and maybe two/three orcs. My Partners third account, gated in, clicked the box and instantly had about 300 orcs on the char in one massive spawn and he was dead before he could even insure the item, in fact he didn't even 'see' the item, wasn't even sure if he even got it just saw the box that opens then he was dead, we then spent the next thirty minutes calling in chat for assistance, he and two others died over and over again , while my char tried to keep em alive so they could try and find bodies under the hundreds of dead orcs, sadly the spawn was so thick it was impossible as the second they click on bodies they just got nailed again. Bad timing, but still, it is poor management on the part of the EM's and basically left a really bad taste in the mouth. He and the other char didn't get either body back as they decayed before the orcs were clear enough to get in without getting totally swarmed.
Now he doesn't have a gift and can't get a replacement.
I wouldn't care how hard it was if the item was blessed or if you could get one on each char etc, but when it is one per account and the item isn't blessed it just means that you basically miss out even tho you participated. It wasn't that bad for maxed chars, but his account only plays Atlantic infrequently so the chars are far from max and their gear is not great. Anyways, just my opinion and I really don't care if others think it is ok for some chars to lose their gifts, I don't.