Sometime this month I'm going to try to get around to doing some FAQ updating. But, here's a start.
(Compiled from the other FAQs in this sub-forum)
BOD values are calculated via the following Formula (PV = Point value)
Count PV + Quality PV + LBOD Bonus (if Applicable) + Material PV + random bonus (Applicable only to LBODs, and only the higher types)
Blacksmith:
1. Count Points:
10 for 10-count BODs
25 for 15-count BODs
50 for 20-count BODs.
2. Quality Bonus: Add 200 Points if Exceptional
3. LBOD type (if an LBOD)
Polearm, Ringmail: 200
Chainmail, 6-part weapon (Sword, Axe, Mace): 300
Fencing: 350
Platemail: 400
4. Metal Type
Iron: 0
Dull Copper: 200
Shadow Iron: 250
Copper: 300
Bronze: 350
Golden: 400
Agapite: 450
Verite: 500
Valorite: 550
Low-end BODs (10-875 points)
10 points: Sturdy Shovel
25 Points: Sturdy Pickaxe
50 Points: 45% chance Sturdy Shovel, 45% Sturdy Pickaxe, 10% Leather Gloves of Mining +1
200-375 Points: 40% Prospector’s Tool, 40% Gargoyle’s Pickaxe, 20% Studded Leather Gloves of Mining +3 (may be 45/45/10 – due to typo)
400-425 Points: 40% Prospector’s Tool, 40% Gargoyle’s Pickaxe, 20% Powder of Fortifying
450-475 Points: 90% Powder of Fortifying, 10% Ringmail Gloves of Mining +5
500-525 Points: Dull Copper Runic Hammer
550-575 Points: 60% Dull Copper Runic Hammer, 40% Shadow Runic Hammer
600-610 Points: Shadow Runic Hammer
625 Points: 30% Shadow Runic Hammer, 60% Blacksmith Power Scroll (105 skill), 10% Anvil hued one of the special metal colors.
650-660 Points: Copper Hammer
675 Points: 30% Copper Runic Hammer, 60% Blacksmith Power Scroll (110 skill), 10% Anvil hued one of the special metal colors.
700-725 Points: Bronze Runic Hammer
750-775 Points: Ancient Smithy Hammer (+10 Skill)
800-825 Points: Blacksmith Power Scroll (115 Skill) (highest possible reward for a small BOD)
850-875 Points: Ancient Smithy Hammer (+15 Skill)
High-end BODs (900-1200 Points). All are considered valuable rewards.
900-925 Points: Blacksmith Power Scroll (120 Skill)
950-975 Points: Golden Runic Hammer
1000-1025 Points: Ancient Smithy Hammer (+30 Skill)
1050-1075 Points: Agapite Runic Hammer
1100-1125 Points: Ancient Smithy Hammer (+60 Skill)
1150-1175 Points: Verite Runic Hammer
1200 Points: Valorite Runic Hammer
Tailor:
1. Count Points:
10 for 10-count BODs
25 for 15-count BODs
50 for 20-count BODs.
2. Quality Bonus: Add 100 Points if Exceptional
3. LBOD type (if an LBOD)
4-part (all): 300
5-part (all): 400
6-part (all): 500
4. Material Type
Cloth: 0
Leather: 0
Spined: 50
Horned: 100
Barbed: 150
Smalls:
10-25 points: Cloth type 1
50-75 points: Cloth type 2
100-125 Points: Cloth type 3
150-175 Points: 90% Cloth type 4, 10% Sandals (can be of any of the cloth 4 or cloth 5 colors)
200-275 Points: 80% Cloth type 5, 20% Sandals (as above)
300 Points: Stretched hide deed. (only overlap between small and larges, unlike smiths)
LBODs:
300-325 Points: Stretched hide deeds (2 sizes, 2 facings)
350-375 Points: Spined Runic Sewing Kit
400-425 Points: 105 Tailoring Powerscroll (40%) or Tapestry deed (2 types, 60%)
450-475 Points: Bear Rug Deed (2 facings, brown or polar)
500-525 Points: 110 Tailoring Powerscroll
550-560 Points: Clothing Bless Deed
575 Points: 115 Tailoring Powerscroll
600-625 Points: Horned Runic Sewing Kit
650-675 Points: 120 Tailoring Powerscroll
700-800 Points: Barbed Runic Sewing Kit
What really sucked is that the EA/Origin changeover removed the original sources for the point values, and I had to use other posts and the Stratics Tailor BOD Reward Calculator to reverse-engineer the points values for tailor, while posting it.