Not going to get involved in all the detail, I have read the entire thread, and I'm not going to respond to each bit, but just my overarching viewpoints.
Re the original topic, I at least believe his posts are always polite, and can be agreed or debated against politely. Yes he may post too much, yes I and everyone else may respond too much, I think maybe the best tactic is to respond less, be clear in what you say and why you agree or disagree with him, and move on. I believe an above poster in this thread said a similar thing, and I would agree. I think his weakness is he cannot ever change his viewpoint, no matter how clear you are in your logic, but so many are the same I guess.
Re Sampires… I have clearly said in the past Sampires should be deleted. Sounds controversial when I say it like that I guess. To be a bit more logical, and a bit less controversial - I agree with many players who think that Necromancy and Chivalry just should not go together. From a game lore point of view, it is just a mess, and the result is a mess. They are super powerful, but I'm not going to go so far as saying they can solo everything ingame, I accept they have some weaknesses, and the Devs are working against them in more recent content. I think Sampires add a lot in terms of new player go-to character, trading, crafting and economy in that every player wants one, and they go to a lot of effort with equipping them and their various slayer weapons. I really wish that effort went towards the more pure classical warrior styles, archer, thrower, paladin, samurai, swordsman, fencer, macer etc. I wish Healing was stronger, and outweighed Hit Life Leech and Mana Vampire combined etc. I just feel the entire concept of a Sampire (Paladin+Necromancer) causes philosophical issues for UO, and real balance issues, whereby it almost negates much of the entire Warrior class, which is a huge shame.
Edit - due to tiredness, I made a mistake by focussing purely on Paladin/Chivalry, when I also mean Samurai/Bushido (the military Nobility of Japan)+Necromancer.