Not really a test topic, so I thought I'd compile this list here.
So far:
Deep Water (in the seas between seamarket and fire island)
amberjack
Black Seabass
Blue Grouper
Bluefish
Bonefish
Bonito
Cape Cod
Captain Snook
Cobia
Gray Snapper
Haddock
Mahi Mahi
Red Drum
red Grouper
Red Snook
Shad
Tarpon
Yellowfin Tuna
shallow water (by the cliffs of Fire Island volcano and New Haven)
bluegill sunfish
brook trout
green catfish
Pike
pumpkinseed sunfish
rainbow Trout
redbelly bream
smallmouth bass
uncommon shiner
walleye
yellow Perch
So far:
Deep Water (in the seas between seamarket and fire island)
amberjack
Black Seabass
Blue Grouper
Bluefish
Bonefish
Bonito
Cape Cod
Captain Snook
Cobia
Gray Snapper
Haddock
Mahi Mahi
Red Drum
red Grouper
Red Snook
Shad
Tarpon
Yellowfin Tuna
shallow water (by the cliffs of Fire Island volcano and New Haven)
bluegill sunfish
brook trout
green catfish
Pike
pumpkinseed sunfish
rainbow Trout
redbelly bream
smallmouth bass
uncommon shiner
walleye
yellow Perch