Alot of players (including myself) thought that Shard of the Dead was purposely made to determine interest in a Classic Shard, but made terrible enough so no one would play it, giving you guys an excuse to axe the Classic Shard / Shards option (which was done anyway)
But yeah Shard of the Dead was horrible, nothing resembling a Classic shard, but thats what alot of players thought.
Personally ive always been nuetral on the Classic Shard option. Myself and many other vets will continue to play both Mythic UO and free servers, or only free servers.