Well, when it was on TC I tried to see if I could get positive loyalty back down to unknown, I was unable to do it. Not saying you can't, I just never figured out a way too. What I am doing with one of my characters tho is going total evil to all towns. I am killing rioters which makes you disloyal. Doubtful in the long run that will be a good thing *shrugs* but I do like to do the unpopular thing on occasion. If you are unable to get it to where you are loyal to just one, you may consider doing that OR going loyaly to all and just see what chaos that causes you in the long run.