Thanks for the detailed information! It doesnt mention anything about that kind of a loop in the faq, is it yet another bug like crustaceans being weighted less? Because it makes no sense whatsoever.
I see these fishmonger quests as a kind of bod system for fishers. However, this kind of a loop is not present on the current bod systems. Imagine getting bod orders with less quantity for every time you reach the maximum (coincidentally 20) or normal quality orders when you complete exceptional ones. All of a sudden, rng seems less evil, isnt it?
I've noticed that I'm not having any fun completing these quests, even when I get good orders or recieve better rewards. The only reason I still complete these quests is for getting a 120 powerscroll so that I can try to catch some of the rare fish or maybe finally be able to successfully fish in the lava (still cant catch anything in lava at elder fishing) in an effort to document these.
I truly blame myself for not testing these fishmonger quests enough on the high seas beta shard. If I could spare a few more days to see if I could get at least a 105 fishing ps, maybe I could offer some kind of a comment prior to the release of the booster back.