Hi, you might remember me from such films as "the newb who posted the ultimate Siege QQ thread" .... haha
For the record, I've come to appreciate being killed by Krystal and Elvis a myriad of times and looted up and down. For starters, I carry a leaner pack, and they've taught me a most important lesson on Siege...don't carry it if you can't stand to lose it.
If you've ever happened to check the "criticism of Ultima Online" wikipedia (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Ultima_Online) there is a section called griefing with a quote from Ralph Koster (Designer Dragon):
"Being safe from evil is, in my mind, an uneven tradeoff for the fact that you don't get to be heroes anymore, in that you can just opt out of fighting evil. It may be
nobody wants to be heroes except when it doesn't count, when it isn't challenging,
that people would rather fight "pretend evil" than the real thing, but I don't personally believe that. I still think people are better than that."
When I read that quote, I reflected on the options that I had considered as an alternative to being killed and dry looted by Krystal. I considered playing another server, and I considered playing another game altogether...
The most interesting thing about that Ralph Koster quote is that he is WRONG. Karl Marx made some poignant criticisms of capitalism, but he was WRONG in the sense that he believed people wanted something different...if they did, we wouldn't have eons of greed to prove otherwise. If Ralph Koster were right, Siege Perilous would be so crowded you couldn't move in the Luna bank...and World of Warcraft would be bankrupt.
But that isn't the case, and we all know that. We also know why...it's because 10 million people are off fighting the fake evil. You're right...even TnT posters...despite being somewhat demeaning, you were helpful so I will say thank you. You said pick up your sword and do something about it. That I did, that I did...
If it isn't clear yet what I'm saying, let me hit you over the head with a hammer. In every other game (and life) the good guy wins. I was so used to a decade of gaming where I took for granted the fact that being the good guy and winning are synonyms. Here's the great thing, I realized it has been a decade of fail...haha. So I'm here to stay, and I'm working my skills, and some day I'll prevail in the face of evil. This is precisely the kind of player Siege needs.
But allow me to get to the point that I believe the original thread does. If you have to kill NEW, so be it...you just might be doing them the biggest favor in their gaming career. Like the Ralph Koster quote says, I was challenged by real evil and forced to make a decision, and my decision was to strike back. I am in fact grateful for that.
I don't agree that picking up the NEW books fits under the same umbrella. As far as Krystal and Elvis slaughtering helpless newbs...I believe it is analogous to building a clinic for paraplegics with no wheelchair ramp...the ones that are determined enough will find a way inside...and that seems to be TnT's mentality on new people joining the server. So be it. Cruel world indeed, but I see those people crawling, biting, clawing ever day on this server. They'll get inside.
If you haven't seen where this is going though...stealing new books is like putting people in the wheelchair. We are just talking about something cruel and unusual. "COUNT ME OR I LOOT YOU"...ok, I actually can see how TnT might defend that as "evil roleplay" but god is it a STRETCH of some VERY thin material...
Picking up NEW books is not evil roleplay though. That's called being a selfish prick. I don't know Java of MYTH, but that's a shame.
I don't know if that was a joke about Krystal passing out the books, but I hope it wasn't. If the Siege community has that kind of duality then it's doing well. I think it's ok to say "I want you to be here, I'm going to kill you, but I want you to be here"...I don't think it's ok to say "I don't want you to be here". After all there are human beings behind every single one of these computer screens. I appreciated the fact that Krystal and Elvis both posted in my thread. When someone treats you that way sometimes you just have to know there is a real person behind that screen, and not a machine.