Anyone who ever thought anatomy was useless has never played a weapon-using character. Even mages get an average of anatomy & eval int as a defacto defense-only wrestling skill for reducing hits on them, when holding a spellbook, and many (if not most) spellcasters these days have at least one Mage Weapon, that the anatomy skill can boost the base damage up to 65% (120 skill; it's skill/2, +5% at GM or higher).
Were the persons making that ludicrous claim ones that only played stay-at-home crafters, merchants, bards & tamers? Those are the only ones where Anatomy wouldn't have a use.