They need to continue this way and they ll have no more customers... I can tell you many of my friends, and the French community are very unhappy about that expansion.
1) BUGS
Personnally I didn't buy it, but it s sad that instead of fixing long going bugs, this expansion just put back old ones... aka controlling 2 summoned daemons at once etc... I will say it again, any serious company fixes bugs before releasing an expansion, particularly when they have magic incomes coming every month in the form of subscriptions.
2) SCATTERED ACTION
Seas used to be like half of the landmass. Completely unused. So that expansion suddenly brought in game like twice as much land. Resulting in UO looking like a solo game even more than before (tbh I m not really concerned about that, as far as I have a few friends to play with if I want to, but I know people are concerned about that).
3) Translated quotes from the French forums.
the french : badly designed, badly developed, but as far as they ate our 14 bucks I guess they are happy.
Jack Beauregard : Let s hope next one in 6 months will be better.
Alaster The Mad : When you are in a boat, player movement is still not smooth at all. Cannons are extremely expensive... It may take forever to find an npc boat. The command "start tracking" is very inaccurate. Repairs are insanely expensive as well. Fighting the pirates is fun but I really hate that gold sink aspect.
Ankh Magister : Very little content added. New artifacts are horrible, 2 bosses including one that is a joke. Piratery has to be avoided unless you have a jackofall trades craftsman. There is a new mysticism bug. I thought that expansion would be great but I feel like having been sod.....d. That content is all about losing our times travelling on the sea. 15$ for new boats and 2 bosses including one completely stupid and very long to do with that... And since I dont care about fishing there is really nothing for me in that. And having to pay once for EVERY account just to be able to go into boats with friends...
Myrielle: In the past they sold us 20% storage increase for 20$ so 15 is an improvement. Besides that, it doesnt deserve to be called a booster... EA is making lazy money. No more birthday gifts, no new rewards, unless you buy them for real money on an online website... I am bored to be taken for a milk cow and letting my account open hoping for an hypothetic good add on. Does anyone know if it is still possible to sell accounts for real money?
T.Mesdo: Seriously, after what had been posted about that booster, you really bought it ?!?
Mahd: Our monthly fee is high enough like that, I didn't buy the booster...
Many people did excited posts about the booster, but noone posted anything positive since they got to try it....