I'm at work, so I can't ask him, but I can pretty much guarantee that wasn't about you Aeric.
I don't recall any negativity associated between you and I^A. It think it was directed towards someone whining because he's not accepted in Iantown.
I am no longer in the guild I^A, but the rule of Iantown was always that people are accepted into Iantown regardless of color (red, grey, blue..whatever). He earned the title of being the first person not accepted into the town due to how he behaved while in the guild and then after he left the guild. The town had the goal of being a nuetral town, open to all playstyles.
However, someone who was accepted in the guild who then began to create issues through lying and manipulating, in an attempt to fracture the dynamics of the guild falls outside of the general rule, since they've created animosity on a personal level. While in general all people are welcome, someone who has acted maliciously toward guildmembers on a personal level (not through game mechanics and role playing) way beyond the realm of "gameply" has lost the right to be accepted into the town, imo. I don't think that is unreasonable.
[Edit: he answered...I guess that's waht I get for trying to write a post at work with a gazillion interruptions and results in the post taking over twenty minutes to complete]