scripting is the same as duping - both are illegal cheats. And, the way the BOD system works now, unless you have an Asian sweatshop, having more than 3-4 accounts will give you more BODs than you can fill and request new BODs for.
Most of the current Valorite Hammers are the result of dupers getting a few completed (but not turned in) Val Ex 20 Plate LBODs, duping the book they were in, pulling the dupes from that book, putting them into the first book, then repeating hte process several times. 3 becomes 6, 6 becomes 12, 12 becomes 24, 24 becomes 48, 48 becomes 96, 96 becomes 192, 192 becomes 384 (and that only counts as 77 items, the way BOD books work).
Then, they redeem the BODs a few at a time, and sell them at multiple points in Luna (vending with different accounts than the ones that duped and store the BODs, to reduce the chance of losing it all if they get caught - after all, if the dupe was a transfer-based one, they will typically have $100+ of transfers as an initial investment to pay off, and look to make $600-1000 profit above expenses when all the BODs sell).
I personally know a few legit super-BODers - and the typical Valorite hammer vendor has the ability to sell & restock more Val hammers in a WEEK than they can get in 6-12 months, using multiple BOD runners and active traders of BODs.
The proof needs to go the other way - anyone who can restock more than ONE Valorite hammer a week EVERY WEEK, for months, is a probable duper/scripter. Remember, I had to RUN the numbers of the BODs last year, to test the changes that were made.
Tailoring:
Larges are the only rare BODs (8.5% of all BODs, but BRK larges are STILL 1.8% of all larges by my testing). This is about the chance to get a Valorite BOD of ANY type, let alone one that fits a large with any worthwhile reward). 18 (yes, EIGHTEEN - count them) different Tailor LBODS give Barbed kits.
As a result, MORE THAN ONE IN EIGHT smalls by type, before factoring in rarity from leather type, fit Barbed Kit Larges*. Once you factor in the split for leather types (and the cloth/leather divide), 3.6% of all Tailor BODs are Barbed Kit BOD smalls.
For Smiths
25 weapon smalls + 24 Armor smalls for iron = 49; x 6 = 294 distinct Iron smalls (for 48 larges). Note that 66 of the smalls (over 20% aren;t even combinable with a large.
Under normal circumstances for a 120 smith, those Iron BODs make up 55% of the Smith's BODs. (50% weapon, plus 10% of the 50% that are armor BODs)
Armor types:
24 smalls, x 6 for quality/count = 144; x 8 for colored metal type = 1152; 528 of thise are NON-COMBINABLE.
Total distinct smalls: 1446 (almost twice the number of tailor smalls).
Number of Verite Runic smalls: 18 (12 valorite, 6 verite)
Number of Valorite Runic Smalls: 6
24/1446 = 1 in 60.5 (compare to about 1 in 7.5 for Barbed Kit smalls). Now, factor in that TWO of the Barbed kit larges are SPINED LBODs (If you consider cloth = iron, and regular leather = DC/Shadow, Spined is the tailoring equivalent to smith's Copper & Bronze BODs!), while Valorite smalls combined are 2% of all smith BODs, and that 3/4 of those won't be plate, half of the plate won't be exceptional, and that even adding in Verite Ex plate 20 for the easiest Verite hammer still won't do more than raise the chance by about half, compared to just Valorite plate ex (verite is about 50% more common than valorite for BODs, but only 1/3 are going to be specifically 20 count). From my testing, about 0.2% to 0.25% of Smith BODs (1/500 to 1/400) are Verite/Valorite Hammer smalls, compared to 3.6% Tailor smalls for Barbed kits(1 in 27.5). That means that the tailor runics smalls are 30-40 times more common - and that's for any BOD for any set. Getting the 6 specific you need for a specific LBOD, that gets even more astronomical for smiths, going into the probabilities, without serious trading partners.
No way in hell that ANY ONE operation is legitimately getting 50+ Valorite hammers a year. Sorry to rain on your fantasy parade.
*****************
* The math for the tailor BODs, if you don't believe me:
Cloth smalls: 7 LBODs*3 + 2 LBOD*4 (the hats, with no footwear, and the Town Cryer; footwear goes into the leathers) = 29 types, x 6 for the different qualities and counts = 174 distinct cloth smalls.
Leather smalls: 1 LBOD*4 + 2 LBOD*5, 2 LBOD*6 = 26 types, x 6 = 156 smalls per leather type; x4 for the different leather types = 624 distinct leather smalls
174+624 = 798
18 Barbed kit larges
16 are 6-parters = 96 (2 spined, 6 horned, 8 Barbed larges)
2 are 5-parters = 10 (2 barbed larges)
106/798 = 13.28%
1 in 8 is 12.5%
1 in 7 is 14.2857%
