Maybe I should just come to my senses and agree with what you say... but I can't help but giggle a bit at this:As much as i'd love a dip into the past, those days have gone.
New players just wouldn't like the "vanilla", what made it great was the fact it was new back then.
The awe at talking to somebody ingame and finding out they lived on the other side of the world.
The sense of wonder and excitement at being able to fight your 1st undead after hours training on innocent goats ect.
The Role Play also made it what was so good that after 20 years we still fondly remember it but again, those days have gone.
No, it's best to keep those things cherished memories and not destroy them by having a "midlife crisis UO shard".
"New players just wouldn't like the "vanilla"" - funny you say that because I don't think new players would even like the current UO! I was just on ATL for a bit sitting at the bank and saw someone riding a horrendous looking unicorn (WTF?!?) next to someone on a bright orange horse while another person was dressed like a multicolored glow stick you would see at a friggin EDM concert - this game has been so badly tainted beyond recognition which is why I would like to revisit the good ole days (even if it dissappoints)!