"6. Parry has little effectiveness IMHO. It's simply not worth the 100 skill points."
To my (PvP) experience, 120.0 Parry is crap.
Parry is designed in a way that it will save you Vs. 4-5 targets because it will block 2 or 3 out of 5 incoming hits often enough to net out an adequate reduction in damage taken within a certain time period.
Meaning it's best-suited for PvM, in situations where you are castly outnumbered.
Try this: Go to Jhelom Pits and attack ALL the fighters there. You will get excited and think that Parry WtFPwZ.
Now go to Yew Gate Fel, and try to fight a single target.
Vs. a single target it will block a single hit out of.. 10? Or so. You will actually be asking yourself WTF happened to your 120 points. The difference of how fast and how much damage you receive in PvP and how often is enough to render your Parrying useless. It's even worse than basing your Defense on Attunement because it's more random than shielding yourself 100% from the next 40ish Dmg and because the hit you will Parry might be a simple, pure shot and not a Special Move even.
Also there's a myth that needs busting; that of Parrying working wonders Vs. Special Moves. Go out and try it, it's totally random.
On the other hand there are SOME times when it works (IMHO) as it should and you block enough to think you will keep it just A TAD longer to make sure, but believe me in the end you'll just dump the skill like I'm doing.
An argument I saw from Archers in the recent heated convos about Archery being OPed is that over-cap DCI and 120.0 Parry pwns Archery.
It's not constantly being at 45% DCI *AND* Parry that will save you if it does. It's plain simple JUST the 45% DCI.
The RNG seems to be so much more fair for the DCI chances than for the Parrying chances really, to the point where you don't NEED Parry when fighting single targets, running around and whatnot. You simply don't stand there either so there's no case of thinking "Okay I stood there, took so many hits on my shield that netted me x2 my HPs over 5 mins so Parry saved me".
However that does not mean that all the Archery hating was uncalled for. It doesn't mean that WITH Parry you will be EVEN BETTER Vs. Archers either just because you will block 1 out of 10.
That is not enough to justify the argument of Archery fans that you just need to adjust and get Parry AND DCI.
So how does it NOT mean Archery hating was uncalled for? Because Archery has all the benefits of Melee but is ranged and can hit on the run just as effectively(Moving Shot hits my max Physical when wearing reward robes for 25!!!). You can even disarm someone by sacrificing a few skill points, and yes you're still an Archer even if 1 out of your 12 Attacks is a melee one to Disarm.
In the same sense that blocking a single hit doesn't justify 120.0 Points nor is it the solution of all Archery related problems.
Recap : Archery will hit you as much as melee, from RANGE, WHILE MOVING. For too much damage. Because Archers can just run away (while shooting too, direction doesn't matter) and need neither Parry nor DCI except to fight other Archers. That takes care of the Archery Vs Parry+DCI = Dead Archer argument. Back to topic.
Some will argue that Bushido+Parry is the new Parry, I say CRAP. Again, the RNG is much more random than DCI's or simply too random- PERIOD.
Also most Bushis will have 1Hand because of Pots(*HINT* Pots are OPed, especially NORMAL HEAL Pots boosted with EP instead of GHeal.. And Poisons Vs. Pots = Imba and there no solution, gotta be re-designed). And if you want numbers just go compare 120.0 Parry + Shield Vs. 120.0 Bushi/Parry + 1Hand. The difference in blocking is not impressive and in action, UNNOTICABLE.
So go find my post where I mention I stoned 120.0 Parry, notice the date and count up to today and you'll see how much time I've been trying Parry both in PvM and PvP. Then add the months I've spent with Parry before stoning it in the first place.
I give you no theories, just what happens in action. Whether you wanna believe it or hide behind sheets of data and Stratics links, is up to you.
I wrote all this so that MAYBE it will add up to the momentum that's pushing people to ask for some Non-Caster Warrior love. So that MAYBE we can get some.