You're right... I'm probably alone in my assessment of the situation. I never, ever had issues on an archer getting looting rights. I never had issues on my mage getting looting rights. I hallucinated it all, and I was just smoking crack.
Sorry... I must have left my swords of prosperity in my other robe. Not quite sure what this has to do with my assessment of the situation other than you clearly had decent luck on a particular template. Congratulations. In my experience, that wasn't the case, and on my archer, I think I was lucky enough to get looting rights once every ten kills.
Every time, right? I somehow doubt that.
Actually, I have avatars for warrior/mage/tamer. And I have faced issues with getting looting rights on all 3. Note that for boss mobs like peerless, daemon berserker, the top 16 damagers gets looting rights, you just need do enough damage to knock off the 16th damager.
It all depends what I'm fighting and my equipment. In Doom, I do better with my mage. I see other warriors x-heal and kick ass, but my warrior didn't do so well, (I will get looting rights, but I will also die). My tamer did worst (tried beetle/mare combo, cu sidhe and super dragon). Often my pet was taking the damage, but warriors were out-damaging me and knocking me off the top 16.
For travesty, my warrior shines! Tamer sucked. Mage sucked worst. Actually, before they nerfed Swoop, my warrior would out damage mages/tamers and get 75%-100% looting rights.
Against Melissande, my tamer worked better than my warrior or mage.
Against Melissa, my tamer and mage did just as well. But I used explo pots for other chars including my warrior.
Finally, if you are referring to the SIX, there's no looting rights required. Everything dropped on the ground. Not sure if it will be different this time though.