I'm a bit embarrassed to admit I caved in last night and bought both packs for the account that has my Siege crafter. Just started a shop on Siege a few days ago as a trial to see if I can stand the merchanting profession and it was annoying to see stuff on crafting gumps she couldn't make! So I buckled.
The only thing is now I have stuff in the house that can only be used by ONE damn character, since you only have one character per account on Siege. The chest of sending has a big fat message on the side that says it requires the Gothic theme pack (and no, it won't send containers to the bank) and the advanced training dummy that would be lovely to use for my newbie swords character also requires that theme pack.
Fortunately, though, someone from NEW was able to use an advanced training dummy I set up last night. He trained 0-60 in swords and wrestling in just a couple of hours. He was also surprised to find out that the dummy hit him back, so to speak, so he could gain in healing and also got some great focus gains.
The dummies don't look anywhere as bad as the pictures I saw earlier, thank goodness. And they can be erected in houses that are not updated with the booster pack. House owner and co-owner characters without the Gothic booster pack can re-deed the advanced training dummy but cannot place one from a deed.
The raised gardening bed can be placed and planted by a house co-owner or owner character on an account updated with the Rustic pack. There's no way to set the access on the bed, however. After it is placed, only the co-owner character (and maybe other chars on same account, but I can't verify that on Siege) can access the plants, as well as an owner of the house where the bed is located, even if the house owner account is not updated with the pack. Even if the house owner account is not updated with the Rustic pack, the house owner can empty a bed placed by a character on another account and can also axe it to re-deed it. However, once re-deeded, the bed cannot be placed again except by a character on an account updated with the Rustic pack.
The rustic bench and the ritual table can be placed (they are crafted as deeds) by characters on accounts not upgraded with a booster pack. I have no hedges yet to use to make topiary, so no comments on those yet. The liquor barrels are cheap to make but are not containers and when you click on them tell you that they are for distilling. The metal kegs are also cheap to make and open up for any character (upgraded account or not) like other kegs so you can use them for storage. Haven't tried to make a distillery for lack of copper wire and no thief to get it.
Haven't tried either new tile set yet and won't be able to experiment with them because the house on the account that has both packs on it just became a shop and I'm not about to fiddle with it anymore, new tiles or not!
I haven't tried out the encampment system yet. Will probably go check later to see how expensive the bidding is on Siege at this point and maybe will set up a vendor. Seems I heard you can use them to indicate what you want to buy (may be wrong), so I might try it out just to see how that works for buying certain commodities. Have been trying to acquire a few relic fragments to make soul forges with so maybe it would be ideal for finding a seller for those who will take my puny order....
Overall, at this point, I'm definitely feeling like I overpaid for what I got. Most of the new stuff is okay and even useful, to a degree. However, some things have shortcomings, especially if you have not upgraded all your accounts to use them. I think selling the contents of both packs as ONE pack for about $10 would be a much better value. (Would like to say the cost should be even less than $10, but then that would leave the cost of other single items in the game code store REALLY out of whack.) $15 is too much, especially considering that an SA upgrade these days purchased from the game code store only runs $19.99.
Lastly, I have a feeling more people are buying the packs than you might think from reading in UHall.... So although we may be giving EA all kinds of feedback here (good and bad), I have a feeling it may not be a good indicator of what the population as a whole is already doing or may do over the course of the next couple weeks.