Forsythe was pretty good, he still lost to Babu. Iron Fist also lost to Babu (and badly.)
Bill Nye was good (So was Arthurs Knight) but he wasn't any where near the best. XH cross sharded with guilds like PK HQ n ****. I actually played factions with them on Atlantic because we were so bored dominating everyone (no one would raid us) that I split off and PvPed with the Cats guys to spice **** up.
Funny you mention Cadul because he got steam rolled by Babu and Sweet Death too.
Cadul was always considered the best UO:R dueler. In P16 it was guys like me, Forsythe, Revinence, Cadul, etc. AOS dueling mostly died. Pre UO:R(Not sure when you guys invaded) it was Decay. When XH came to Chessy they got beat down BAD. They came when archer mages were big and Anat+ Eval = wrestle was first introduced(Right around p16 I think) and couldn't hold up against any guild. I used to have lots of pics of like them, M, and a few other Chessy guilds have some HUGE battles at Brit GY.
That is what I liked about Chessy, there were so many different guilds, and sometimes we did "color" wars where all the guilds would break off, and we'd do an NFL style recruitment process, and your ex enemy may be your new Roger Wilco target caller. Memories