You obviously do not pvp and do not understand the importance of mage weapons without a weapon skill. Would i pay 100m for his weapon---if it had a big hit spell to. Would i pay 50m for his weapon? ---yea
You are absolutely correct that I don't understand PvP weapons at all. Why is this weapon better than my Swords of Prosperity which has MW -0, SC -0, Luck 200 and FC +1? I can get those anywhere for 800K to 2 mil each.
Just this week I threw out a maul with MW -20, SC -1, DCI 6 and DI 36%. No one wanted it at any price. I got that one from Miasma. I had a Halberd (also from Miasma) with MW -20, SC -0, SSI 30%, DI 30% and couldn't sell it. Mage weapons with SC -1 in my experience aren't that rare...
I did a quick inventory check of Mage Weapons that I had on my vendor that wouldn't sell and are sitting at home. Here is a sampling:
Heavy Xbow: SC -0, MW -21 plus fire/energy damage
Elven Machete: MW -23, SC -1, HML 60%, SSI 10%, DI 25%
Black Staff: MW -24, SC -0, SSI 20%
Bow: MW -22, SC -0, DI 37% plus fire/energy damage
Cleaver: MW -20, SC -1, Air ele slayer, HLA 18%, HLL 12%
Composite Bow: MW -22, SC -0, SSI 35%, DI 30 (I may use on my tamer)
Crescent Blade: MW -20, SC -1, HSL 36%, HLL 40%, DI 37%
Magical Short Bow: MW -22, SC -1, Hit Fireball 30%, SSI 25%, DI 38%
I have quite a few more, but none would sell. I don't do PvP but run across lots of these types of weapons in PvM loot and seldom bother with them any more.
So, and honest question: What makes a really good PvP weapon?