http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qSlDZ27BAY&feature=related
First off let me just say, you're wrong. In what nation, army or kingdom is there no penalty for murder? Can you answer that? Crimes like this are punishable by death and those who wish to conspire face the same.
If someone kills you they should face the same law no matter what guild, alliance or faction they are in. There is nothing more to it. If you wish to kill, it is your choice but you will be punished for it. Fact, people join guilds just to kill the weak and uninsured. What right do they have to use one rule set to get around another so they can abuse it over and over without penalty?
You need to stand up and do what's right. No more hiding behind a screen and taking advantage of the rules and the weak, simply because you can. What does that say about a person?
If you kill or steal, there must be a penalty because you are breaking the law. What more does one need to know?
No one is telling you that you can't keep doing whatever it is you do now. The only change would be that you would be held accountable for your actions. Why do people fear this? Why are they afraid, just so that they can continue to make bad decisions?
Then, I suggest we change and grow and do what is right and join the Righteous. This is not a 2 way street. If you kill someone then you pay the price, not say Oh that was my guildmate, my brother, therefore it's ok, he doesn't like the game anyway.
You asked about my experience, what experience do I have? I started playing long ago and was showed the game by the best. I was in The Clan Of The Highland Knights, where we were brothers and sisters. The GM would not let me do all what I wanted to, with laws, rules, titles and changing to a much larger group. So, as Second In Command Of CHK, I left to start COS.
COS is older than 10 years. I have added thousands of members personally and I know what guild pks do. They like killing smiths and people away from keyboard or men with nothing more than a robe. I have seen hundreds leave the game because they could not get past the types of people who promote the killing of the weak. This is the shame that is created and it disgusts me to no end.
People think that because you can kill, it gives you power, but against me you are powerless. History will show time and time again, that any system without law will fail. There must be penalty and responsibility. I ask that we all say these words a few times and really think about it.