Luckily a macer can use a Whip or War Hammer in the Void Pool. You can Use WW the whole time. Eventually you get to a point where you quit hitting the pirates.
My setup is almost exactly the same. The template generally excels at tanking, so I wanted resisting spells on there since it helps a lot with many monster types. Having everything 120 sometimes isn't strategic, especially when certain skills over 120 aren't providing huge benefits.I have a Mace and Shield Paladin Warrior which runs the following:
120 Mace Fighting
120 Tactics
100 Parrying
120 Chivalry
090 Healing
090 Anatomy
080 Resist Spells
I run with slayer sets of Barbed Whips and Hammer Picks for weapons. Human race. Suit is all plate/ring for stamina protection. 190+ stam, 149 hit points. 15 HPR, 15 MR. I recently revamped this character from Swords and Bone/Stud to Macing with the Plate and I've been enjoying it. I have a pretty Uber shield to make it work to hit all the mods I am aiming for. That's pretty important for any template with a Shield. You can find a good shield for pretty cheap, but getting a top end shield can be a game changer for a build like this.
There's also a few threads in the Warrior sub-forum on Paladins: