I loved the jwilson slimes. J wilson imo was a bad reporter... He basically said UO is a bad game because when he logged on to check it out, he couldn't just stand around the bank begging people for stuff and having them give him everything he wanted.
His biggest gripe was that he couldn't be anti-social and have the players give him everything he wanted. So basically, he didn't rate the game... he gave the game a bad rating because players found his anti-social behavior annoying.
History showed him for the fool he is, though. UO is still here 10+ yrs later. I think his review of UO was probably the worst game review EVER.