My uncle and I use to team up to do High Seas ship raids... back when it was new. It was a lot of fun.
Worked out a great system to keep the NPC ship from "floundering" so we couldn't attack it... with success. He would work the boat while I controlled the cannons.
Problem is... it was so long ago, I dont remember who I used from my team. I have several specialized huntresses... mainly use a tamer with discord, but it couldn't have been her. Had to be a peace-mage. I also could have had an archer sitting hidden, after the ship was disabled and a few grape-shop rallies didnt kill them all. Stealth-mage could board, hidden... peace and attack.
Either way... it was highly effective. Made me wish they would raise the difficulty AND rewards. A few crates of special booze was hardly worth bothering with. Now? I dont think it would sell at all. I also completed a orc ship... or whatever they are?... I forget. BUT I have one. Purple.
Clearly.
I think that was the thing. After several weeks of raiding adventures on the seas... the thrill wore off fairly quickly. Not to mention the extreme issue trying to reach the docks thanks to the grand blockade. As I said before, I have sold SO many cannons, cannonballs, and tools for the cannons... over the years, the gold is far better then anything we could get raiding. Its like being the only shop selling mining tools to the thousands of miners in the gold rush. So many of them got nothing. The guys selling supplies cleaned up. hehe