Although after spring cleaning I wonder how many were actually kept. I did keep a selection so at least I have one and two handed weapons for all skills.
kept the best 4 weapons I had, which is one from each combat type. In otherwords, 1 bow, 1 sword (butcher knife actually, but it's a kickass one), 1 kryss, and 1 mace. Everything else that I had left was turned in. I really didn't see any point in keeping what I had any longer. Anything that was any good was sold when Moonglow started back up, so what was left was junk anyway.
I've gotten over my pixel packrat stage and now only keep things that I actually use. No more sets that will sit in chests for years and never get used for me. I even turned in my complete set of cursed arties other than 2 Orny's that I am still using on my crafters. I freed up over 1000 storage in my house and feel good about it.