You should have had more options. For the most part, I'll board with just about anyone. Sometimes I'll check gags, but that's only to see if that person has gags more over the levels. With rare exceptions, if someone has a sell suit, then they've earned the right to go into the VP. So long as they have gags (and I don't mean 1 of every possible gag nor do I mean all their weakest gags but none of their strongest), then I'll board. IF, however, they have no gags, are missing important/strong gags, need a major toonup, any number of other inconsiderate things, then I won't board with them. Once in the VP, if they aren't playing for the team, then I'll be inclined to not help them survive (I will NOT sacrifice the team to save someone who endangers said team).
So you should have had "Gags matter", "Suit level matters", "Suit level and gags matter", "None of the above". Something to that affect.
I voted "no", but what I stated above is how I really feel.