I don't recall the OP asking for it to be handed out.
I could have sworn she asked only for there to be another quest for it so that it may be earned in another way since there is no longer a way to earn ophidian loyalty points anymore.
She never asked that it be easy.
I have the recipe on both shards I play, my husband put in a monumental effort to obtain it for my Siege character.
It was damn hard to get the recipe, ESPECIALLY, since the time to build up the lot of loyalty required was LIMITED since the Event had a limited life.
Meaning, that those players who put their efforts into getting the recipe had to forget doing much else in the game during that limited Event time (unless they had extensive time available to play Ultima Online during the Event life...).
Having a new Quest, ongoing, WITHOUT a limited time frame as it was during the past Event will definately make it easier since one could be able to build up the loyalty a little at a time, since there'd be no deadline to meet in a short period of time as it was during Event.
That is, in order to even try to get close to how monumental the effort was to get the recipe during the Event limited time frame, a new Quest would need to require at least TRIPLE that loyalty if not more, since there'd be no limited time frame to complete it as it was for the limited time Event.
But that's not the point either.
I missed the Invasion spellbooks which are VERY effective for a mage.
So, I ask then that ALSO those items are brought back again.
And since we are at it, I also happen to like very much the Dread War Horse, also these should be brought back. I do not see why a player should have to spend 20+ millions on these War Horses pretty much as one finds it annoying to spend a few gold points to buy Blackrock Stew from other players........
And the list of Event items to bring back should get quite longer.......
Nope, I really see NO POINT nor reason to bring back Blackrock Stew recipes.
As it has happened before AND it will happen again in the future, sometimes players get to earn the Event items, sometimes they don't. In the long run gains and losses eventually should even out if they get to participate to some Events and not to others.
Accepting the idea to bring back 1 Event item to respawn means doing the SAME for any and all past Event items. Either no to all or yes to all. Bringing back Event items to respawn, selectively, ain't a good way to go, IMHO.
Bring them ALL back to respawn or NONE.