[Discussion] Anyone compared drop rates from the Magincia quests?

[Basara]

Some of the items seem to be WAY too common.

Here's what I've gotten with my 18 characters on Lake Austin

Quest 1: Miscellaneous (note, I forget which quest gives what).

Analysis: Fairly balanced.
5 Pots
5 Moongate stones
4 square boulders
4 tapestries


Quest 2: Furniture

Analysis: Off kilter a bit.
9 shelves (these wouldn't have been so bad, if they'd actually been containers, but they aren't)
4 Pulleys
3 coatracks
2 canvas racks.


Quest 3: Wooden Items

Analysis: You're joking, right?
9 Piles of Logs
7 Dead Trees (which you can't even position in most containers, so you got to remove them all to see if anything is underneath them)
1 Dishing Stump
1 Pier piling



Frankly, I'd have liked to have had 1 dishing stump for each of my forge areas (my two accounts with full-time crafters), plus one to keep for a set in my museum. And, I don't think I've ever seen a pier with ONE piling.

Note that the sheer number presented means that at least one of my accounts produced nothing but trees and logs (actually, two of them did - I finished the set on my first, 7-character, account - and didn't start getting tapestries and coat racks with the other quests until I got to those accounts, either)

 

[TirNaNo'g]

I did the quests on 14 characters and this was the results:

Quest 1: Miscellaneous

5 Pots
2 Moongate stones
1 square boulders
6 tapestries


Quest 2: Furniture

1 shelves
3 Pulleys
5 coatracks
5 canvas racks.


Quest 3: Wooden Items

3 Piles of Logs
3 Dead Trees
0 Dishing Stump
8 Pier piling

I finally just gave in and bought a dishing stump off a vendor.

 

[Esmeralda]

Well I´ve done the mag quests with my 2 accounts too.
The thing I got most are the coat racks followed by the rubble boulders (wich actually were quite annoying me, since I have 2 originals from magincia´s destruction....).
I didn´t get a single pier piece nor shelves...lol.

To me the drops it seem completly random.

 

[Farsight]

On 5 characters: 14 quests (only did 4 fate quests)

Repeat items:
2 hat racks, 2 dishing stumps, 2 pier pilings, 2 pullies.

Didn't get:
Pot, tapestry (traded for those)

Got one of everything else.

 

[RedRum]

MISC
Pots - 9
Moongate stones - 8
Boulder - 6
Tapestries - 5
(two characters to finish quest with still)

FURNITURE
Shelves - 6
Pulleys 10
Coatrack - 8
Canvas painters rack - 6

WOODEN ITEMS
Pile of Logs - 6
Trees - 8
Dishing Stump - 6
Pier Piling - 10