Lord Sergonar finished reading aloud the proclamation and put the scroll back down on the table. "Long live the king!", he called out. The rest of the high council remained silent. "The royal council has spoken", scolded Sergonar. "The throne is Casca's and we have sworn an oath to that throne. Through these long dark hours when our lands are invaded time and again, Casca has commanded the defense. He is the last of the Royal Council and the only who could by right or tradition defend the throne. And we will show him our support."
There was a strained silence through the dusty chambers.
"He defends the throne from a healthy distance, does he not?", challenged Lord Eternos at last. Looking up to meet Sergonar's stern gaze. "Years ago you told me that there are two castles in Britain. You said that in one once sat a man of honesty, compassion, valor, justice, sacrifice, honor, spirituality and humility while in the other sat a man of chaos. Did you not say that time in again throughout history, individuals have been drawn to the castle which most suits their hearts? Which castle do Lord Casca's cannons now defend?"
"Portents and signs aside, there are matters of law and tradition to consider", added Lord Woodwalker. "The royal council was assassinated ... wiped out. With the assaults upon our many cities, Casca had a strong hand in shaping the very council which has bestowed this honor upon him. The legitimacy by which he has ascended to this position, however logical, is tenuous."
"I would go further", interrupted Lord Maplestone. "Consider for a moment the manner of his assent. The people love him out of hatred of the invasions. The courage to put him on the throne comes from fear of the enemy." Maplestone tossed down the papers collected during the quest to rescue of Casca from an unlocked chamber in a deep dungeon. "Add the names and our enemies do not add up. Avery is a good man. And if he is not the traitor, then who is? What if the truth is a falsehood."
"My old friend", started Lord Salthook. "You know in your heart, as we all do, that something here is terribly wrong. We all want a king. We all want back the spirit of ancient glory that guided our lands and every other land we have encountered. We do not know if Casca's heart is good or ill, but can we say that he is the paragon of virtue that makes him the first to be worthy to sit upon the throne in all the years we have been in these lands?"
Sergonar stood and turned away, looked back to argue, but words did not come.
"The people love him", warned Lord Tempest. "As a fellow elf, even I have have admired Casca's rise to this human throne. We are not one of the great houses of the land ... and even if we were certain of his unworthiness, our voices would not sway many."
"As far as I know, the royal guard are absolutely loyal", stated Sergonar slowly, pensively. "If an oath of loyalty is demanded, a refusal will be noticed quickly. Our station, honorary though it is, would be endangered ... and with it our titles, our lands, perhaps even our very lives. This is a lot of wager on hearts and hunches and letters of ancient, untested law. So be it. But let us risk no others, wrong no others and move quickly and quietly to find the truth."